Family Forums
Parenting Forums
Pregnancy Forums
Adoption Forums
Fertility Forums






Members List Photos Events Local Adoption Support Search Arcade Reviews Membership Upgrade
Welcome to the Forums. Register
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ. You may have to register before you can post or search: click here to proceed. To start viewing messages, select a forum below that you would like to view or click View All of Todays Posts.
Forum Categories
User Name
Password

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old 08-01-2006, 07:47 AM
Mamma Mamma is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 423
Total Points: 10,910.85
Donate
My MIL read the AP article; how would you handle her comments???

Hi everyone - Well, my MIL read the Guatemalan adoption article that has hit just about every paper around and has had numerous phone calls from "friends."

Her opinion? Well, she thinks the agencies are taking our money and giving us a picture of a baby we'll never meet. Eventually, we'll realize we've been "taken" for our money and will have no baby. If by some miracle we do adopt, it won't be the baby we have in our pictures. Geez.

This is the LAST thing my husband needed to hear. He was a little leery of the entire international adoption process anyhow and was concerned about where the $$ was going (although he initiated the process in the beginning). And there's been a minor mixup with our DNA results/picture .... so that's not helping any either!!

When things get difficult, guess who gets ALL the questions!!! Yep, me!

I know how I will handle this.....and I'll be nice about it. I disagree with what they say about not coming home with a baby - I've seen tooooo many beautiful babies here!!! However, I can't disagree with the high risk of international adoptions. Those of us who have investigated the process before we dove into it completely understand those risks. Evidentally, as I was discussing the risks, my hubby must have had his fingers in his ears .

Thanks for letting me vent. Any advice.....send it my way!!
__________________
Mamma

Proud mamma to two little miracles!
(03' domestic agency & 07' private attorney)

2007 - Failed international adoption

Our family is complete .... unless God has other plans for us!
Reply With Quote
Click Here for More Information
Guatemala Adoption Information

  #2  
Old 08-01-2006, 07:59 AM
WesieMom's Avatar
WesieMom WesieMom is offline
Senior Member

Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 1,843
Total Points: 1,125,969.63
Donate
Believe it or not, everyone in my family has seen the article and not one person has said anything. I guess they are taking it with a grain of salt.

I don't have really any big wisdom for you to fend off the MIL's comments. Other then reassure her that you have done your research and there are risks any where you adopt and there is always bad apples everywhere. And then tell her you have alot on your mind with the process and that you don't need anymore unwanted stress. So, unless she has legit concerns or comments, that you would prefer not to hear them.
Told you I didn't have much wisdom...lol..just my own opinion.
Good luck & big hugs!
__________________
*~Lisa~*
*~Mommy of 3~*
7/27/06~Entered PGN!
8/25/06~Kicked out of PGN, error on Guatemala side
9/8/06/~Found out we were kicked out of PGN
9/22/06~Back in PGN
10/27/06~Kicked out yet again, error on Guatemala Side
11/10/06~Back in PGN
12/12/06~One year ago today we started this process
12/27/06~OUT OF PGN!
1/19/07~New BC received
1/23/07~Submitted for PINK...
1/25/07~PINK
2/1/07~Leaving for pick up
2/2/07~Visa Appointment
2/6/07~Home forever!
4/16/07~Readoption completed

http://our-journey-for-sophia.blogspot.com/
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 08-01-2006, 08:02 AM
Mat012 Mat012 is offline
Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 59
Total Points: 1,108.34
Donate
I wrote an "essay" addressing the article and the side of things that it didn't address. I posted this on our journal website and was proactive by asking friends and family to read and become more educated. I asked them to be aware that most of the adoptions in Guatemala are NOT unethical and that the article had a negative slant and was focused on the unscrupulous people out there - not on legitimate agencies and people that we are dealing with. We have had nothing but support and positive comments back from our family. I hope you can help educate as well.
__________________
Melany
We have a beautiful 3 year old son!
And now... our daughter Pilar - born 7-04-06! Home Forever 1-09-07
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 08-01-2006, 09:29 AM
lisam951 lisam951 is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 991
Total Points: 4,210.69
Donate
Well, I don't really have any good advice on your MIL, but where is she getting that people are paying for an adoption and not bringing home the baby? I didn't see that in the article. To me it implied that adopting a baby from Guatemala was TOO easy, also untrue.
__________________
Lisa
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 08-01-2006, 09:57 AM
lmvsmom's Avatar
lmvsmom lmvsmom is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 959
Total Points: 17,422.16
Donate
My advice is to set boundaries with MIL ASAP. Let her know in a kind but firm way, that you won't tolerate negativity. Legitimate questions are fine, but she needs to believe in what you are doing for your family. You don't need the stress she's adding to the situation. Good luck!
__________________
Tina
Thankful for a smooth adoption and proud mom of a precious Guatemalan boy!
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 08-01-2006, 10:10 AM
TerriBB's Avatar
TerriBB TerriBB is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 1,653
Total Points: 6,656,551.84
Donate
I guess I'm lucky, my mil only reads the tabloids... . My heart is with you and I too am so sick of the horror stories!!
__________________
Terri
AJ- (bio) 6 years, he is
Princesa Flora 3 years (home at 51 weeks) - home the day we won the 2006 World Series!
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 08-01-2006, 10:17 AM
jlinberger's Avatar
jlinberger jlinberger is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,409
Total Points: 15,323.98
Donate
Have her come talk to us online here, we'll let her know that we all get our babies!
__________________
Jennifer- mother of Antonio Carlos
5/10/04- DOB
Referral of Antonio 6/1/05
147 days in PGN....
3/18/05- Home forever!!!
Waiting for Gabriella Ingrid.....!
1/20/06- SURPRISE!!! Agency call of inquiry for
newborn sibling of Antonio
2/7/06- Full referral
2/23/06- Dossier and all acceptance docs DONE!
3/25/06- I-797C received! (I-171H equiv)
6/7/06- DNA authorization and entered FC
6/15/06- DNA and FC interview
6/23/06- Positive DNA match!!!
7/18/06- Pre-approval
7/28/06- Exited Family Court
8/16/06- Entered PGN
9/27/06- OUT OF PGN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
9/16 or 9/17- Submitted for Pink
9/19- NOT GIVEN PINK for missing cable 37
10/31- Embassy appt.
11/3- Home forever!
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 08-01-2006, 10:20 AM
angieandstever's Avatar
angieandstever angieandstever is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 555
Total Points: 12,199.74
Donate
I would probably first tell her not to believe EVERYTHING the media writes. Then I would explain that with any adoption there are risks and that is why you selected an agency which is licensed or has a great reputation, with happy clients, etc.... You get the picture. I would state that you did your research and feel confident about your decision. I would also explain with all adoptions there are risks though, not just with international adoption.

Good luck. MIL's are unique and that's all I am going to say!
__________________
Angie


It's a girl!!!!

09/01/2006 DOB
09/13/2006 DOR
09/25/2006 DNA Done
10/04/2006 In FC
10/11/2006 FC Interviews Completed
11/09/2006 Received PA
11/17/2006 Exited FC
11/24/2006 Entered PGN
01/18/2007 Exited PGN !!!
01/30/2007 PINK!!!
02/06/2007 Embassy Appointment
02/08/2007 Home

Reply With Quote
Click Here for More Information

  #9  
Old 08-01-2006, 10:22 AM
Lori Elena's Avatar
Lori Elena Lori Elena is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 461
Total Points: 18,058.76
Donate
Let us help you. Post the name of the agency you are using and ask anyone who is using, or even better, has used this agency to respond with their experience and even pictures of the precious babies brought home to their forever familes. Then, print out the responses and show them to your MIL and your DH.

JMHO.

Lori
__________________
Homestudy completed 2/17/06
I-171H received 3/9/06
Dossier submitted 3/22/06
Referral 4/13/06 DOB: 2/5/06
Accepted referral 4/22/06
Entered FC 5/16/06
DNA done 6/6/06
DNA results 7/1/06 It's a match! 99.94%
PA issued 7/3/06
Unforgettable Visit Trip 7/18-7/26
SWI 7/21/06
SWI report received 8/18/06
In PGN!!!! 8/22/06
KO 9/6/06
Back In PGN!!!! 9/7/06
We're OUT!!!! 10/12/06
Home Forever 11/3/06

HERE WE GO AGAIN!!
Gianna Nicole born & referred 8/20/07
Dossier received in Guat 9/6/07
Received 171-H 9/20/07
DNA Testing 10/2/07
Awesome Visit Trip 10/13/07-10/20/07
DNA Results Rec'd - 99.99% 10/15/07
SWI 10/22/07
PA 11/21/07
Into PGN 12/20/07
OUT!!! 2/6/08
Submit for Mixco BC 2/11/08
Received Mixco BC!! 4/2/08
2nd DNA done 4/8/08
DNA received at lab 4/10/08
DNA results at USE 4/15/08
PINK!!!! 4/16/08
Embassy appointment 4/25/08
Home Forever 4/29/08
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 08-01-2006, 10:57 AM
Clare'sMom's Avatar
Clare'sMom Clare'sMom is offline
Luckiest Mom In The World

Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 1,710
Total Points: 9,054,742.96
Donate
I'm so sorry for you!

I am the Adoptive Mom poster child in my area.... and Not One person I know has said a word to me about the article....

I don't think anyone really cares! Crazy Tom Cruise and Pamela Anderson must be bigger headlines....

The MAN did make a couple of points that no-one can argue with, and we have all heard about a thousand times about every country we adopt from, but the rest was just CRAP!

We have two Daughters from Guatemala at home (both are two yrs old) and we have a seven week old son who is still there. I know for a fact that both of my daughters ARE the babies whos photos we received. We received hundred of photos os each..... And I have almost 200 photos and a DVD of our son, so far, so I think I will know him when I see him. You will also know your child, I am positive of it.

All of the fees that we paid were right in line with what we expected to pay someone to take care of our children for MONTHS untill all of their paper-work is in order.
Break it down.... $18,000.00 paid to an attorney. For what?
How about Dr's care,
Diapers,
Formual,
cloths,
Foster Mother,
Transportation (it's a big city and gas is $$$$)
people to pre-pare all the paper work,
go to court,
pick-up and drop off papers,
and the Attorney, in the US we pay attorney fees and don't bat an eyelash,
the list goes on and on... by the time its all said and done, you can account for almost every dollar.

If you DMIL says anything else about it. ignor her! It's so not worth your energy. If you husband is afraid, tell him there are hundreds of children that come home every year with no trouble what so ever!

You are a much bigger person than I am, I don't think I could or can be that nice....

Best Wishes for the you and your child. I pray it is a speedy journey!!!

Ann
__________________
Ann
The Worlds Most Grateful Mum of 10!


Three Big Kids #1 03/01/83, #2 07/27/84 & #3 02/19/87

#8 It's A Girl!
Beautiful Girl ~DOB 7/13/04
In My Arms 11/06/04
Clare Kicked The Pants Off Leukemia 11-06 to 05-09!!!

#7 It's A Girl
Our Gift ~DOB 06/29/04
In My Arms 11/07/05

#10 It's a BOY!
What A Doll! DOB 06/10/06
In My Arms!! 12/05/06

#4 What A Joy
DOB 12/06/1994
In My Arms FOREVER!!! 02-01-09

Our Angels
#5 DOB 7/12/99
#6 DOB 5/20/01
#9 DOB 8/15/04
In My Arms FOREVER!!! 06-30-09
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 08-01-2006, 05:58 PM
tybeemuffin's Avatar
tybeemuffin tybeemuffin is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 916
Total Points: 47,071.68
Donate
Tell her you have a bigger shot of getting to KEEP the baby than you would have with a domestic adoption!
__________________
Jan. 2005: Hired Agency / Started Process
5/1/05: HS Complete
5/7/05: Fingerprinted
6/13/05: I171 H
7/11/05: On the "List"
12/26/05: My Baby Girl is born
1/18/06: Referral
3/31/06: PA
4/11/06: in PGN
5/15/06: PGN KO
6/2/06: PGN Re-Entry
6/18/06: Visit Trip
7/24/06: Notified OUT OF PGN (Dated 7/7/06)
8/2/06 PINK!
8/9/06 Home Forever in the U.S.A.




Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 08-01-2006, 06:12 PM
monalouise's Avatar
monalouise monalouise is offline
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 534
Total Points: 9,397.99
Donate
If it is any comfort, I completely relate. Several members of dh's family called to tell us about the article. We said yes we read it and told them not to believe everything they read.

Of course my MIL thrives on doom and gloom. It is her life. So she takes some sort of pleasure of thinking there could potentially be a problem. She is a drama queen to say the least.

I guess the best thing to do is like the previous poster said, ignore the negativity. Prove them wrong when you show up with your new baby!

Good luck!
__________________
Jennifer
Mommy to Nikolai (b. 2-24-02 Moscow)
12-25-05 baby girl born
3-18-06 INS approval/officially accepted referral
5-4 DNA
5-18 DNA Results
6-21 PA
June-26 PGN
Nov. 9: told our case was approved, just needed to be signed off
Dec. 18: Informed that we were given our 4th kick out, this time by Barrios himself
Jan. 10: Informed that we were approved by our new reviewer, now waiting for director and Barrios' approval again!

Feb. 5, 2007 OUT! OMG!

April 3, 2007: Redo fingerprints, unbelievable!!!

Will I ever get pink?

FINALLY PINK! May 2

Embassy appt: May 11
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 08-01-2006, 07:19 PM
TBJS's Avatar
TBJS TBJS is offline
Junior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 41
Total Points: 362.34
Donate
I was skeptical of the process too, before we started. So, besides my two Guatemalan children I now have at home as proof, I have several ideas.


1. My wife had confidence because a friend at work had used our agency (although through Korea, not Guatemala) and her son was 14 years old at the time, so they had a legitimate track record. Get all the info you can about your agency, length of time in business, other children that have come home through them etc.

2. Find a local adoption support/interest group were families get together and bring her. Our agency just had a picnic last weekend with too many families to count with children from Guatemala and elsewhere. Also, here in South East Michigan this weekend there is a picnic for families with Guatemalan children. Also too many families for me to count.

Seeing all these beautiful children will convince anyone.

3. This forum is great proof that it is legitimate. Yes, lots of families have delays of some sort but the overwhelming majority of children come home to their families and those that don't have some legitimate reason.

4. Tell your family it's your decision and that you only need positive support or to leave you alone.

As an adoptive parent who has been through the process twice, I was amazed at the article. The one statement sounded like the attorney just took the baby and handed it to the adoptive parents. No mention of all the U.S. paperwork prior to even starting the process in Guatemala. No mention of family court and PGN. No mention of the U.S. Embassy in Guatemala and the processes there.

I just feel sorry for those who work at the Marriott. We stayed there 4 times and everyone was wonderful. I hope there is no backlash towards them there.
__________________
Terry

Dad to two Guatemalan Children:

Son - Josh, 4 1/2 (home from Guatemala Feb 2003)

Daughter - Sofia - 27 months old
Refferal - May 31, 2005
Visit - July 11-14
Pre-approval - Aug 3
Out of PGN - Sept 27
GCBC - Oct 22
Lost documents????
Pink - Nov 18
Appt - Nov 30
Home - Dec 2, 2005!!!

Last edited by TBJS : 08-01-2006 at 07:28 PM.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

Points Per Thread View: 1.00
Points Per Thread: 15.00
Points Per Reply: 5.00


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:00 AM.