I second the Dutailier. We chose one that reclined with an ottoman. I love the recline. I do wish we had gotten one with a taller back though. You get to pick your fabric and wood color too. We went to a local store to test them out and then bought one online for a couple hundred dollars less than the store charged. This is the site we bought ours from
Dutailier Glider Rockers and Ottomans at BabyCatalog.com
They gave me great customer service too. One of the snaps on the arm rest pad broke when I was putting it together and they shipped a new set of arm pads to me. After using it a few months the metal stop for the recline started making a creaking noise in the upright position and they sent me a whole new frame and paid return shipping on the old frame. I was really suprised that they gave me no grief at all with this, just did it.
Now I guess you could say you shouldn't have these kinds of issues when you spend 700.00 on a chair but I'm happy to know they stand behind their product.
We also plan on using this chair for a very long time, which is why we spent so much.