Hmm, I never thought about the choking factor but that makes sense. I think I'll stick with giving him peanut butter but spread thin so it won't be a choking hazard. Interesting to read all the replies and different points of view on it. As far as seafood goes, my DH gave Jake a tuna sandwich once. Then another time he gave him fish tacos. I said to him both times, isn't that seafood? He was like oh yeah, I forgot. And he is the one freaking out about the peanut butter!
So can they not have seafood because of allergies too or is it for things like mercury?