My 3 yo wants Kaya because she looks like Pocahontas, and is an "Indian Princess" just like her. Hard to refuse that logic. We have been over that catalog so many times it is worn out
Interestingly, she has never given Josefina a second glance...Felicity is her second choice---probably because she likes her clothes. And yes, we already have Bitty Baby...her godmother got her started on that for her first birthday.
If your DD is old enough, why not fork over the catalog and let her pick?